LuggageSearch

Guides

Best Carry-On Luggage: How to Actually Choose One

Updated September 2026

Most "best carry-on" lists are ranked opinion, not criteria. This guide flips that: here's what actually determines whether a carry-on works for you, in order of how often it causes problems at the gate.

1. Size — and why it's not one number

There is no universal carry-on size. US majors (United, Delta, American, JetBlue, Alaska) generally allow up to 22 x 14 x 9 in (56 x 35 x 23 cm). Budget European carriers are stricter for the free allowance — Ryanair's paid Priority bag tops out at 55 x 40 x 20 cm, and its free personal item is smaller still. Gulf carriers like Emirates and Qatar Airways cap cabin bags at just 7 kg, regardless of how well it fits the sizer. If you fly multiple airlines, buy for the strictest one you use regularly — not the most generous.

Use our carry-on checker to test a specific bag's dimensions and weight against 16 major airlines at once, rather than looking each one up manually.

2. Empty weight of the bag itself

On weight-limited airlines (most of Europe, the Middle East, and Asia — unlike the US, which rarely weighs cabin bags), the suitcase's own empty weight eats into your allowance before you've packed a single shirt. A hardside spinner can weigh anywhere from roughly 2.5 kg to over 4.5 kg empty. If you're flying Lufthansa (8 kg limit) or Emirates (7 kg), a 4 kg bag leaves you only 3–4 kg for everything you own on the trip. Check the empty weight before you check the size.

3. Hardside vs. softside

Hardside (polycarbonate or ABS shell) protects contents from crushing and is easier to wipe clean, but has fixed internal volume — what you see is what you get. Softside bags (usually nylon or polyester) flex to squeeze into tight overhead bins and typically have more exterior organization pockets, but offer less protection for anything fragile and can look worn faster.

There isn't a universally "better" choice — see our Samsonite vs Delsey comparison for how two major brands approach this differently across their carry-on lines.

4. Wheels: spinner vs. inline (rollerblade)

Four-wheel spinners roll in any direction and are easier to maneuver one-handed through crowded terminals. Two-wheel inline bags are typically more durable (fewer moving parts to break) and easier to control on slopes or uneven ground, but require you to tilt and drag them. Most modern carry-ons are spinners; inline wheels are now mostly found on rugged/outdoor-oriented luggage.

5. Expandability

An expandable zipper adds roughly 2–5 cm of depth when unzipped — useful for the trip home when you've acquired souvenirs, but be aware that expanding the bag can push it over an airline's size limit. If you plan to fly with it expanded, measure it in that state, not collapsed.

6. Laptop/tech access

If you travel with a laptop, a carry-on with a dedicated front-loading laptop compartment (or a slim secondary bag that fits under the seat) saves you from repacking at security. Not all carry-ons have this — it's worth checking before you buy if you fly for work.

The bottom line

Pick your size and weight ceiling based on the strictest airline you actually fly, not the most generous one. Everything else — hardside vs. softside, spinner vs. inline, expandable or not — is a preference question with no universally right answer.

Have a bag already?

Check its exact dimensions and weight against 16 major airlines in one go.

Open the carry-on checker →

Sources

LuggageSearch is reader-supported. This page may contain affiliate links — see our disclosure.